MY THEORY ON THE SECOND ‘TORTURER’!
So recently I’ve been thinking. These messages that the liars received in 4x23 ‘Unbridled’ are NOT signed by A. I do not think these are A messages. I think the liars are being attacked and threatened by two lots of people: Big A (and/or A-Team) and THE PERSON IN ALISON’S GRAVE.
This theory is focusing on the second torturer: the person in Alison’s grave.
What does this mean? How can the liars be attacked by the person in Ali’s grave? I don’t mean this literally, what I mean is that I think the person that is in Alison’s grave is THE TWIN OF SOMEONE STILL CURRENTLY ALIVE, and the twin still alive is sending these messages and threatening the liars FOR KILLING THEIR TWIN.
IT MAKES SENSE! Look at the notes the liars received in 4x23. The person sending these messages is referring to THEMSELVES being the dead one, but obviously they are just writing metaphorically and don’t literally mean themselves… they are talking about THEIR TWIN which is technically them self as they’re kinda the same person, if you know what I mean.
I THINK THE PERSON SENDING THESE MESSAGES IS THE TWIN OF THE PERSON THAT HAS BEEN BURIED IN ALISON’S GRAVE AND IS FIGHTING FOR REVENGE FOR THEIR DEAD TWIN.
ONE OF THE TWO TWINS IS STILL ALIVE AND IS AIMING FOR REVENGE FOR THEIR DEAD TWIN THAT IS IN ALISON’S GRAVE.
I can very clearly see this as being endgame; how it all started with twins and one was killed by one of the liars, and the other twin wants revenge on the liars by constantly torturing them.
I really can see this as being endgame and this whole time, everything has been run by the twin that is still alive, whilst the other is dead.
And just to quickly add, I think this is all different to A.
-A is a totally different story line and person.
-A has their own motives.
-A is someone else.
I think there are 2 groups of ‘bad people’: this twin and then A.
This is important to note!
WHAT DO YOU ALL THINK? I actually really really like this thought, I do think it is realistic given that Sasha Pieterse (Alison’s actress) has very clearly stated that Alison does NOT have a twin, but SOME ONE ELSE may have a twin. Is this what she was hinting at?